DealBuddi POWERED BY SALES MARKET FIT
Sign in Book a call
← All resources
Article · Gavin Tye

It's Not a Sale Until the Contract Is Signed: Lessons From a Lost $3M Deal

Cover: It's Not a Sale Until the Contract Is Signed: Lessons From a Lost $3M Deal
THE SHORT ANSWER

A sale isn't won until the contract is signed. After two years and being named preferred supplier on a $2–3 million government contract, we lost at the last step because our startup's financials looked risky. Nothing is "just a formality": influence the buyer's whole journey and frame every piece of information for their benefit.

This is the story of what was, at the time, my best-orchestrated sale. It took two years and we celebrated before the final signature.

What happened?

In 2015 I joined RedEye, an Australian startup helping large organisations manage engineering drawings. When mining crashed, we pivoted into water utilities. A pitch event at one of Australia's largest capital-city water suppliers in 2017 opened the door to a 24-month enterprise sales process.

We made countless trips, got to know the executive team, demonstrated domain expertise, showed our culture and out-served larger competitors. Unknown to us, another water utility client helped them write their tender. As a government body they ran a formal tender with a probity period: months of silence where you hope everything is in place.

We went above and beyond in our response and were named preferred supplier for a contract worth $2–3 million over five years. Then they asked to see our financials as "one more formality". Our runway didn't cover the full contract term. The call came: "We want to choose RedEye, but we can't take the risk." Two years, gone.

What are the lessons from losing the deal?

  1. Don't leave the buyer's journey to chance. We got lucky with outside help; you need your own influence and control.
  2. Nothing is just a formality. Consider how every document will be read from the buyer's side.
  3. Service, culture and going above and beyond are hard to compete against.
  4. Reuse the buyer's own requirements. We built on that tender's requirements spreadsheet and won more than $15 million in later contracts.
  5. You can't control every outcome. Do your best and be proud of it.
  6. Never celebrate until the contract is signed.

How would I run this deal today?

I'd help them measure the impact of their current process to strengthen the need, assist with their business case and tender documentation to shorten the cycle, and make sure nothing we shared could be misread.

Frequently asked questions

When is a B2B sale actually won?

Only when the contract is signed. Verbal confirmation or preferred-supplier status can still be reversed.

What is a probity period in a government tender?

It's a period during a formal government procurement where contact with vendors is restricted to ensure a fair process. It can last several months.

Why do startups lose enterprise deals at the final stage?

Often due to perceived risk, such as financial runway, that wasn't addressed earlier. Every piece of information should be framed for the buyer's peace of mind.

How can sellers influence a tender?

By helping the buyer understand and quantify their problem and supporting business case and requirements development early, before the tender is written.

STUCK ON THIS IN YOUR BUSINESS?
Book a strategy call with Gavin and we'll work out what to change first.
Book a strategy call

Keep reading

Article Hope Is Not a Sales Strategy: How to Take Control of Your Sales Pipeline If timelines keep slipping and buyers don't take agreed next steps, you may be running a hope-based strategy. How to spot it and replace it with control. Read more → Article The Hidden Cost of Ignoring the Buyer's Journey in B2B Sales Discovery, demo, proposal isn't a buyer's journey. Here's how guiding clients through their buying process cut our sales cycle and lifted tender win rates above 90%. Read more → Article How to Shorten Long B2B Sales Cycles: What Actually Works Approvals, unclear value, distractions and unfamiliar buying processes stretch B2B sales cycles. Here's the two-step approach I use to shorten them. Read more →